WhatsApp Steph

15-2-1 (Level 1, Room 7), Jalan Setia Prima R U13/R, Setia Alam, 40170 Shah Alam, Selangor · Mon–Fri 8:30am–5:30pm

Home / Insights / Terminating a Probationer

Recruitment · Compliance

Can you terminate a probationer in Malaysia? The law employers get wrong

Probationers are not free to dismiss at will — they carry the same just-cause-and-excuse protection as confirmed staff. Here is the correct, defensible process.

By Steph Eng · Carriera·Updated 2 November 2026
Can You Terminate a Probationer in Malaysia? The Law Employers Get Wrong
The short answer

No — an employer cannot freely dismiss or refuse to confirm a probationer in Malaysia. A probationer has the same protection against dismissal without just cause or excuse as a confirmed employee, and can claim unfair dismissal under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967 within 60 days. The correct process is objectives, honest appraisal, a fair chance to improve (or extension), and a due inquiry for misconduct.

Key takeaways
  • Probation is not a right to dismiss at will. Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967 covers any workman who “considers that he has been dismissed without just cause or excuse”, and the courts apply that standard to probationers.
  • The deadline is 60 days. A representation must be filed within sixty days of the dismissal. If the dismissal came with notice, it can be filed during the notice and up to sixty days after the notice ends.
  • Back wages for a probationer are capped at 12 months, against 24 months for other employees. Both caps are in the Second Schedule to the Act.
  • Performance and misconduct take different routes. Performance needs objectives, appraisals and a fair chance to improve. Misconduct needs a show-cause letter and a due inquiry.
  • Never let probation drift. When it ends, confirm, extend or release in writing.

The single most expensive belief in Malaysian HR is that “they’re still on probation, so we can just let them go.” You cannot. Once a person is engaged under a contract of service, the law treats a probationer as a workman who is protected from dismissal without just cause or excuse — the same standard that protects a confirmed employee. Get the process wrong and a non-confirmation or a probation-period termination can land at the Industrial Court as an unfair-dismissal claim.

This guide sets out what the law actually requires, with the exact authorities, so your decision is defensible. It is the same compliance discipline Carriera applies when we place and onboard talent through our recruitment service. Probation is only one of the ways a job ends; our guide to ending employment in Malaysia sets out resignation, termination and dismissal side by side.

§ 01
The myth

Can an employer freely dismiss a probationer in Malaysia?

No. A probationer is not freely dismissable. Malaysian law gives a probationer the same protection against dismissal without just cause or excuse as a confirmed employee, and that protection is enforced through Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967 (Act 177). An employer cannot terminate a probationer at pleasure and will, on a whim, or for an improper motive such as discrimination or victimisation.

This is settled law. The Court of Appeal in Khaliah binti Abbas v Pesaka Capital Corporation Sdn Bhd [1997] confirmed that a probationer cannot be dismissed without just cause or excuse — a probationer enjoys the same security of tenure during the probation period as a permanent employee. The statute itself is the Industrial Relations Act 1967 (Act 177), published on the Attorney General’s Chambers Laws of Malaysia portal. So the question is never “are we allowed to part ways?” — it is “can we show a genuine, fair reason, properly handled?”

A probationer is a workman. Dismissing one without just cause or excuse is unfair dismissal — the same as dismissing a confirmed employee without reason.
§ 02
The right way

What is the correct process to terminate a probationer for poor performance?

For poor performance, the law expects a real, supported attempt to help the probationer succeed before you decide to let them go. The Industrial Court has repeatedly stressed that an employer must not act “mechanically” — a probationer has a legitimate expectation of being confirmed and an implied right to be heard. Follow these four steps and document each one.

1

Set clear objectives

At the start of probation, give written duties, standards and what “confirmation-ready” looks like. You cannot fairly fail someone against a target they were never told.

2

Appraise & document

Run honest mid-probation appraisals. Record concerns in writing, with dates, examples and the specific gap — not a vague “not a fit”.

3

Give a fair chance

Counsel, guide and train. Issue a warning where needed and allow a genuine, time-bound opportunity to improve, with support — not a paper trail built to justify a decision already made.

4

Confirm, extend or release

Decide in writing. If there is still potential, extend probation as the safer alternative. Only terminate when the documented effort genuinely failed.

The 2024 reminder from the bench is blunt. In Adeline Yeoh v Tune Insurance Malaysia Bhd (Industrial Court, December 2024), the Court held that an employer “has an implied duty to hear the legitimate grievances of the probationer” and must guide rather than act arbitrarily; the refusal to confirm after three extensions was found “arbitrary and capricious”, and the company was ordered to pay compensation. The lesson: extensions are not a way to keep someone in limbo — they must be used to genuinely help the person improve.

What if it is misconduct, not performance?

Misconduct is a different route, and it has its own mandatory step: a due inquiry. Before dismissing a probationer for misconduct, issue a show-cause letter setting out the allegation, give the employee a fair chance to respond, and hold a domestic inquiry to establish the facts before deciding. Skipping the inquiry is itself a procedural defect that can make an otherwise-justified dismissal unfair. For genuinely grave misconduct, dismissal may be warranted — but the process still matters.

§ 03
Decision

Confirm vs extend vs terminate — how do I decide?

At the end of probation you must take a positive decision — do not let it drift. Use this table to match the situation to the right, defensible action.

SituationCorrect actionWhat it requiresRisk if mishandled
Meets the standardConfirmWritten confirmation letter; update status and benefitsLow — this is the expected outcome
Borderline / improving with potentialExtend probationWritten notice, a clear reason, defined goals and a fixed end dateModerate — vague or repeated extensions read as keeping the person in limbo
Genuine, documented underperformanceTerminate (performance)Objectives, appraisals, warning, supported chance to improve — all on recordHigh — thin documentation is the usual reason employers lose
Serious misconductTerminate (after due inquiry)Show-cause letter, fair chance to reply, domestic inquiry, then decisionHigh — no inquiry is a procedural defect
Probation lapsed, no action takenDecide now — in writingDon’t rely on silence; confirm or extend explicitlyHigh — conduct can imply confirmation

If probation lapses and we say nothing, is the person confirmed?

Not automatically, but do not rely on silence. Following the Federal Court in KC Mathews v Kumpulan Guthrie Sdn Bhd [1981], silence does not equal confirmation — without a positive act, the probation is generally deemed extended and the person remains a probationer. However, the Industrial Court has held that treating someone as permanent (granting permanent benefits, or leaving them in indefinite limbo) can imply confirmation. The safe rule is simple: at the end of probation, always confirm, extend or release in writing. For how this interacts with notice and termination benefits, see our Employment Act 1955 employer guide.

§ 04
If challenged

How long does a probationer have to claim, and what can they be awarded?

A dismissed probationer can pursue an unfair-dismissal claim under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967. According to the Department of Industrial Relations (Jabatan Perhubungan Perusahaan, MOHR), a workman who considers their dismissal was without just cause or excuse must file a written representation within sixty (60) days of the dismissal, addressed to the Director General of Industrial Relations. The Director General first attempts conciliation; if there is no settlement, the case is referred to the Industrial Court for an award.

The Act’s own words set the test and the clock:

Where a workman, irrespective of whether he is a member of a trade union of workmen or otherwise, considers that he has been dismissed without just cause or excuse by his employer, he may make representations in writing to the Director General to be reinstated in his former employment…

— Industrial Relations Act 1967 [Act 177], section 20(1), reprint published by the Attorney General’s Chambers

The Director General shall not entertain any representations under subsection (1) unless such representations are filed within sixty days of the dismissal: Provided that where a workman is dismissed with notice he may file a representation at any time during the period of such notice but not later than sixty days from the expiry thereof.

— Industrial Relations Act 1967 [Act 177], section 20(1A)

So when a probationer works out a notice period, the 60 days run from the end of that notice, not from the day the letter was handed over.

ItemDetailSource
Claim routeUnfair-dismissal representation under Section 20, IRA 1967IRA 1967 (Act 177)
Filing deadlineWithin 60 days of the dismissal, in writing, to the Director General; if dismissed with notice, up to 60 days after the notice endsIRA 1967, s.20(1A)
ProcessConciliation by the Director General; if unresolved, the Director General refers it to the Industrial CourtDept. of Industrial Relations (MOHR)
RemediesReinstatement, or compensation in lieu plus backwagesIndustrial Court
Backwages cap — confirmedUp to 24 months of last-drawn salaryIRA 1967, Second Schedule, para 1
Backwages cap — probationerUp to 12 months of last-drawn salaryIRA 1967, Second Schedule, para 2

The Act names probationers directly. The Second Schedule, which applies when the Industrial Court makes an award on a dismissal reference, says:

In the case of a probationer who has been dismissed without just cause or excuse, any backwages given shall not exceed twelve months’ backwages from the date of dismissal based on his last-drawn salary…

— Industrial Relations Act 1967 [Act 177], Second Schedule, paragraph 2

The quotations above are from the reprint incorporating amendments up to 1 March 2010, the latest full English text we could read on the Attorney General’s Chambers site. The Industrial Relations (Amendment) Act 2020 changed the next step from 1 January 2021: the Director General now refers an unsettled representation directly to the Industrial Court, with no decision by the Minister, per Skrine. The conciliation route is also described on the official Department of Industrial Relations portal. For the binding text, refer to the Act as amended and the latest practice notes.

§ 05
Protect yourself

What documents make a probationer dismissal defensible?

If you ever have to justify the decision, these are the records the Industrial Court looks for. The absence of them — not the dismissal itself — is what usually loses the case.

  • Signed offer / contract stating the probation period and that confirmation is not automatic.
  • Written objectives & KPIs given at the start of probation, so the standard is on record.
  • Dated appraisals at least once during probation, with specific feedback (not generic).
  • Warning / counselling notes identifying the gap and the support offered to close it.
  • A genuine improvement window — time and help to improve, evidenced in writing.
  • Extension letter (if extended) with reasons, goals and a fixed end date.
  • For misconduct: show-cause letter, the employee’s reply, and minutes of the due inquiry.
  • A written decision letter — confirmation, extension or termination — with clear reasons.

Most of these failures are training gaps, not bad intentions: a line manager who never set objectives, or an HR team that let probation lapse. That is exactly what our HRD Corp-claimable Basics of Writing Human Resource Policies and the Manual programme is built to fix — turning the rules above into the policies, letters and procedures your managers actually use. Browse the full schedule on our training page.

§ 06
FAQ

Probationer termination — employer FAQ

Can an employer freely dismiss a probationer in Malaysia?
No. This is the most common employer mistake. A probationer in Malaysia has the same protection as a confirmed employee against dismissal without just cause or excuse, and can lodge an unfair-dismissal representation under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967. An employer cannot terminate a probationer at pleasure, on a whim, or for an improper motive.
What is the correct process to terminate a probationer in Malaysia?
Set clear performance objectives at the start; appraise and document performance honestly; give the probationer a genuine, supported opportunity to improve (warnings, counselling, guidance); and consider extending probation as an alternative before deciding. For misconduct, hold a due inquiry with a show-cause letter and a fair chance to respond before any dismissal.
If probation lapses and the employer says nothing, is the employee automatically confirmed?
Not automatically. Following KC Mathews v Kumpulan Guthrie, silence does not equal confirmation; without a positive act the probation is generally deemed extended and the person remains a probationer. But conduct that treats the employee as permanent (or unreasonably long limbo) can imply confirmation, so employers should always confirm, extend or terminate in writing rather than let probation drift.
How long does a probationer have to file an unfair-dismissal claim?
Under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967, a workman who believes they were dismissed without just cause or excuse must file a written representation within sixty (60) days of the dismissal, addressed to the Director General of Industrial Relations (Jabatan Perhubungan Perusahaan, MOHR). If the dismissal came with notice, it can be filed during the notice and up to sixty days after the notice ends. The Director General conciliates and, if there is no settlement, refers the case to the Industrial Court.
What can a wrongfully dismissed probationer be awarded?
The Industrial Court may order reinstatement, or compensation in lieu of reinstatement together with backwages. Backwages for a confirmed employee are capped at 24 months of last-drawn salary; for a probationer they are capped at 12 months. A fixed-term probationer’s compensation is generally limited to the unexpired portion of the term.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. For the binding text, refer to the Industrial Relations Act 1967 (Act 177) and the Department of Industrial Relations (Jabatan Perhubungan Perusahaan) under the Ministry of Human Resources, and take advice on your specific case. Updated 2 November 2026.

Train your managers to handle probation the right way

Most probationer disputes are documentation and process gaps, not bad faith. Carriera Academy runs the HRD Corp-claimable “Basics of Writing Human Resource Policies and the Manual” programme — the policies, letters and procedures that make every confirm, extend or terminate decision defensible. Tell us your team size.